Email I received today regarding a “reality” television show depicting a drug court. Since I have a vested interest, I wanted to make sure the information is passed on.
NADCP (National Association of Drug Court Professionals) Position Statement on the Reality Television Show
“Last Shot with Judge Gunn”
On September 26, 2011, “Last Shot with Judge Gunn” — a reality television show purporting to depict Drug Court proceedings in Arkansas — will premiere in national syndication. Although details of the show have not been fully disclosed to the public, NADCP has monitored the publicly available information concerning its development and has concerns about the show’s representation as a Drug Court and its casting of individuals in substance abuse treatment.
Like other court-based reality television shows, great lengths are taken to give viewers the impression that they are watching an official court in action. Teasers for Last Shot with Judge Gunn imply that the show is set in an actual Drug Court.1 A press release dated September 13, 2011, states that “the show features Judge Mary Ann Gunn’s drug court and the real-life consequences of individuals with criminal charges who are battling drug addiction and alcoholism.”2
In fact, Last Shot with Judge Gunn does not broadcast Drug Court or any other official court proceedings.
The Proceedings Depicted in Last Shot with Judge Gunn are NOT Drug Court
Mary Ann Gunn is not a state or federal judge. Ms. Gunn previously served as a Fayetteville, Arkansas Circuit Court judge. While NADCP recognized and appreciates her former service and contributions, she resigned from the bench in June of this year.3 Therefore, Ms. Gunn has no judicial authority over any official court, including any state or federal Drug Court.4
Similarly, although the show is taped in a Fayetteville, Arkansas courtroom, it is not an official proceeding. Instead, the show is taped on Saturdays and the show’s producers pay the county several thousand dollars a year to rent the room.5
Likewise, any “deputies” or “probation officers” appearing on the show are functioning as actors and are not police officers, deputies, or probation officers employed by the Arkansas Department of Community Correction.6
And the “defendants” are actually post-adjudicated offenders who have been sentenced to probation, not to any state or federal Drug Court, and they have agreed to be cast on the television show.7
NADCP maintains that Drug Court professionals owe their primary, if not sole, allegiance to serving public safety and the needs of Drug Court participants. It is contrary to the Drug Court model for any decision, interaction or intervention to be influenced by extraneous considerations, including profit, entertainment value, television ratings, or publicity. Any effort to alter court proceedings for commercial aims contravenes the fundamental legal, ethical and clinical underpinnings of Drug Courts. Furthermore, by leading the public to believe it is an official Drug Court, Last Shot with Judge Gunn potentially threatens the integrity of real Drug Courts in the public eye and undermines over two decades of unprecedented success.
NADCP Does Not Support the Casting of Individuals in Drug Court
In 2010, NADCP convened a national panel of experts in ethics, law, treatment and the recovery community to carefully consider the ethics, benefits and potential risks of televising Drug Court proceedings. NADCP’s Board of Directors concluded on the basis of these deliberations that any benefits that might accrue from broadcasting Drug Court proceedings are substantially outweighed by the potential for serious subsequent emotional, financial or legal harms to the participants and their families. Notably, both the Arkansas Judicial Ethics Advisory Committee and the Supreme Court of Arkansas reached a similar conclusion.8
NADCP Does Not Support the Casting of Individuals in Substance Abuse Treatment
Though Last Shot with Judge Gunn does not cast real Drug Court participants, it reportedly casts individuals in the early stages of their attempt to overcome debilitating drug dependence. Individuals in substance abuse treatment are extremely susceptible and vulnerable. Enticing them to appear on camera and have their struggle forever memorialized on video – and perhaps on the internet – places an unnecessary burden that could jeopardize their opportunity for successful, life-long recovery. At such a fragile point in their lives, they may not be in a reasonable position to weigh the potential risks and burdens they are being asked to undertake, including having such a difficult moment forever available for future viewing by their children, employers, school admissions officers, loan officers or other community members.
For these reasons, NADCP strongly objects to the representation that the television show Last Shot with Judge Gunn depicts a Drug Court, and it urges the actors and producers of the show not to jeopardize the welfare of vulnerable persons in substance abuse treatment.